2008
Amber Holmes -- Southeastern Missouri State
Eliana Mijangos -- Incarnate Word
2009
Alisha Crump --Our Lady of the Lake
DeJuane Alexander -- LeTourneu
Elizabeth Arnold -- Lubbock Christian
2010
Victoria Willems -- Willam & Mary
Kathryn Galindo -ST Mary's University
2011
Sunejiro Agbuke -- Baylor